Manolo for the Beauty » Things I Don’t Do: Liquid Eyeliner




Things I Don’t Do: Liquid Eyeliner

By Glinda

I’ll confess, I’ve never applied liquid eyeliner. 

Does this mean I have to turn in my Beauty Club Card?

I like to look fairly natural, and in my opinion, liquid eyeliner doesn’t usually qualify as “natural” looking.  Add to that the fact that you’ve got to practice with it for a bit to get the hang of it, and you’ve lost me.

I was a late-comer to mascara as well, only wearing it starting in my early 20’s.  My lashes are already pretty long, and I thought I looked a bit over the top with mascara, but I soon came to love it.  Now I wonder how I went out of the house with eyeshadow and no mascara, which now just looks wrong to me.

I wonder if the same would happen if I went the liquid eyeliner route.

However, my current lifestyle of chasing a toddler around the house and ferrying a minivan full of neighborhood kids to school doesn’t exactly scream for dramatic makeup, so I’m hesistant to spend any money on something I might wear only a few times a year.

I currently use a pencil to do a gentle smudge on the outer three quarters of my lash line, and that’s about it.

Tell me, are you a liquid eyeliner person, or do you prefer pencil? Or possibly powder?  Is there a compelling reason I should try liquid eyeliner? Convince me!









7 Responses to “Things I Don’t Do: Liquid Eyeliner”




  1. aurumgirl Says:

    It’s a “look” that can be outrageous, and it can also be very chic, depending on the kind of effect you want to create. But for ferrying around hordes of children, there really is no need for it. Unless you want to do that kind of thing in a dress and pumps, and perfectly coiffed hair.

    When I was in my twenties I bought a little urn-shaped bottle of Christian Dior liquid eyeliner in navy blue. It lasted many, many years though I went through a period of using the blue liner for a specific eye look–very clean, minimal eyeshadow (or white eyeshadow, very subtle) with the liquid blue line, navy mascara, and a red lipstick. It only worked with tailored clothing, or some of the loosely cut but minimalist Japanese designs of the times (like Comme des Garcons designs, back then). Some girls I knew used it to create Rockabilly looks–again, a kind of tailored, dress and pumps look that was slightly more exaggerated (but not as exaggerated as Amy, above) than the dressy/Japanese style I used it for. I like the retro look it creates, it’s minimal and yet very dramatic.

    Pencil eyeliner always gives a softer look, and it’s quite beautiful. But liquid liner makes a very clear, defined line. In my opinion, it takes just as much time to use either well but it’s really all about the way you prefer to look, the style that makes you happiest.




  2. marvel Says:

    Pencil for everyday. Reserved liquid black eyeliner for going out at night in my early-to-mid 20s and wanted a little more drama. Haven’t worn liquid eyeliner for, oh, probably 10 years.




  3. Klee Says:

    With pale skin, hair & eyes, liquid liner gives me a face. It doesn’t have to be Amy Winehouse dramatic (and if she can master it, anyone can). For everyday, I do a thin line, then pass over with powder to soften it. Plumcake over at MftBG had a recent post on waterproof makeup that included a fantastic gel liner.
    There is nothing like liquid or gel liner to bring out your eyes, whether soft or evening dramatic.




  4. Cape Mama Says:

    I have never mastered the art of liquid eyeliner. And now as my 45th looms in the distance, I don’t know that I will.




  5. Nomi Says:

    “I was a late-comer to mascara as well, only wearing it starting in my early 20′s.” This made me smile. I’m in my early 50s, and I’ve never learned to use eye makeup at all. I played with it a little in high school (never eyeliner though!), but as I got into my 20s I just didn’t have time, plus it felt yucky. Those two factors have never changed for me. Should I even bother, now?




  6. SarahDances Says:

    Having used liquid eyeliner for years I recently discovered I actually prefer gel liner in a big way. It gives the same visual effect, but is much more forgiving and really stays put much better than liquid can. I think the one I use is maybelline, and I love it more than words can say.




  7. Kimberly Says:

    “Having used liquid eyeliner for years I recently discovered I actually prefer gel liner in a big way. It gives the same visual effect, but is much more forgiving and really stays put much better than liquid can.” Exactly. Liquid liner feels like a relic, from back in the day when our options were so much more limited.

    I NEVER leave the house without liner, but while I own probably every pencil, gel pencil, cake liner, and powder liner in existence, I don’t bother with liquid liner. It just looks way too harsh on most women (especially fair redheads like me) and takes too much work to get right.












Disclaimer: Manolo the Shoeblogger is not Manolo Blahnik
Copyright © 2004-2009; Manolo the Shoeblogger, All Rights Reserved




  • Recent Comments:








  • Subscribe!


    Publisher

    Manolo the Shoeblogger


    Restore Hormally Aging Skin

    Categories


  • Archives:

  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
  • July 2011
  • June 2011
  • May 2011
  • April 2011
  • March 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011
  • December 2010
  • November 2010
  • October 2010